Free Ebook The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said
It will always be better to discover this publication as well as various other collections in this referred site. You may not should get guide by walking round your city as well as discover guide store. By visiting this internet site, you could find great deals of book from brochures to brochures, from title to title and from author to author. One to keep in mind is that we additionally offer amazing publications from outdoors countries in this globe. So, The Question Of Palestine, By Edward W. Said as one of the collections is really trusted the origins.
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said
Free Ebook The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said
What's title of guide to remember constantly in your mind? Is this the The Question Of Palestine, By Edward W. Said Well, we will ask you, have you review it? When you have read this publication, what do you think? Can you inform others concerning exactly what kind of publication is this? That's right, that's so incredible. Well, for you, do you have not check out yet this publication? Don't bother, you need to obtain the experience as well as lesson as the others who have reviewed it. And currently, we provide it for you.
When you are really keen on what phone call as publication, you will have one of the most preferred publication, will not you? This is it. We pertain to you to advertise an intriguing publication from a professional author. The The Question Of Palestine, By Edward W. Said is guide that constantly ends up being a friend. We advertise that book in soft file. When you have the soft documents of this book it will relieve in analysis as well as bringing it almost everywhere. However, it will certainly not be as tough as the published publication. Since, you could conserve the data in the gizmo.
Yeah, the means is by attaching to the link of guide that are having actually given. From the like, you could reserve to earn bargain and download it. It will depend on you as well as the connect to go to. The Question Of Palestine, By Edward W. Said is one of the renowned publications that are published by the expert publisher on the planet. Lots of people know more concerning the book, specially this excellent author job.
It is not only to give you the simple means however likewise to get the book is soft data systems. This is the reason that you can get guide immediately. By linking to net, your chance to find and get the The Question Of Palestine, By Edward W. Said asap. By clicking web link that is extended in this site, you can go to directly guide website. As well as, that's your time to get your preferred publication.
From Publishers Weekly
Said's controversial but instructive Palestinian interpretation of the Mideast conflict now includes a new introduction and epilogue commenting on the intifada , Gulf war and Madrid peace talks. Copyright 1992 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Read more
Review
"A compelling call for identity and justice." --Anthony Lewis"Books such as Mr. Said's need to be written and read in the hope that understanding will provide a better chance of survival." --The New York Times Book Review
Read more
See all Editorial Reviews
Product details
Paperback: 320 pages
Publisher: Vintage; Reissue edition (April 7, 1992)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0679739882
ISBN-13: 978-0679739883
Product Dimensions:
5.1 x 0.7 x 8 inches
Shipping Weight: 8 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review:
3.5 out of 5 stars
38 customer reviews
Amazon Best Sellers Rank:
#346,258 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
The Question of Palestine is best viewed in two distinctive parts. Part One deals with the historical narrative, the ideas and events that ultimately led to the establishment of the State of Israel on most of Palestine in 1948. The Second part deals mostly with the Palestinian Resistance post 1948 focusing on the Peace Process and the Camp David Accords.The first part of the book is essentially a narrower version of Edward Said's famous work "Orientalism". Whereas Orientalism attempted to cover misrepresentation of the history and culture of the mostly Islamic Near East by "Orientalists" over many centuries, the Question of Palestine focuses on this "misrepresentation" as it related specifically to Palestine and how it ultimately led to wide support in the west to the Zionist ideas and the creation of a Jewish home land in Palestine. The language and style of this book is certainly easier to follow than the more scholarly Orientalism.A most fascinating and enlightening analysis of the support that Zionism received from progressive writers and thinkers of the late 19th Century act as key foundation in Said's narrative. Said proposes that a culture that totally accepted the views of the Orientalist saw itself as inherently superior to the "natives" and thus viewed the Zionist project as a brave mission to bring civilization to inferior cultures / places. Said Portrays a Zionism admired as a more committed and liberalizing colonial movement that actually attracted wide admiration. Said offers a Palestinians version of events that led to the Balfour Declaration in 1917 that is entirely backed entirely by contemporaneous authoritative western and Zionist sources, all meticulously analyzed and referenced.Said's Narrative places Zionism squarely within a "Western" colonial strategy and places the responsibility for the neglect of the rights of the "natives" on Balfour and Britain, as he cites Balfour's elaborating on the impact of his Declaration, clearly aware of the inevitability of displacement of the "natives". While Said made a very strong case for the historical responsibility of Britain towards the Palestinians, he did not seem to develop his ideas into any form of political agenda towards BritainSaid's account suggests that the transformation of Zionism from a secular colonial movement to one that aims to appeal to religious Jews caused considerable friction within the movement with often strong opposition from the original founders to any action or people who would negatively impact the "liberalizing" "pioneering" image of the movement, the image that idealized the movement to the liberals of the late 19th Century.Overall, the first part of the book, which is nearly two thirds of it is well argued and well referenced and indeed as said earlier builds on the huge amounts of work Said had done in Orientalism. While Said unabashedly acknowledged at the start of the book his desire to present the whole "Question" from a Palestinian perspective, he hardly relied on Palestinians sources and based his entire narrative on western & Zionist sources. In doing so he gave him self the freedom to offer a partisan version of history yet succeeded in making it appear as an exhaustive and balanced review that makes his case very well and convincingly.The second part of the book aimed primarily at the history of the struggle between the state of Israel and the PLO and the Palestinian people. Here, Said was offering a political commentary of events that he personally has witnessed first hand or indeed participated or took part in. Said's usual rigorous review and analysis of sources was naturally absent. His views of the PLO appeared largely romantic and he seemed to find excuses for its many failings. His disagreements with Sadat and the Egyptian position on Camp David totally failed to see the Egyptian Israeli dispute as a distinct (yet related) conflict to the Palestinian Israeli conflict. Said's tendency to overlook the different historical narratives within the middle east in Orientalism carried over into his analysis of the contemporarily Middle Eastern political affairs.Edward Said's Question of Palestine is an excellent source for understanding the very sad history of the Palestinians and their blight. His inability to see an intellectually acceptable way forward, his rejection of Camp David and the Oslo Peace Process reflect both his intellectual honesty and political naiveté. Said's more recent writings in The Nation and Al Ahram weekly seem to reflect some changes his views. It is however Ironic that the failure of the peace process that we witness now in 2002 may actually vindicate some of Said's views of Oslo and the whole concept of a "two states" solution.I have awarded this book "4 stars" based on the strength of the first part. The Second Part is 1 - 2 stars at best!
Worth reading if you are a student of this subject. Balanced? Well, not exactly. But how many books on this subject are really balanced? And I'll go one step further -- This book is certainly more balanced than Dershowitz's "The Case For Israel." Don't get me wrong. I'd read the Dershowitz book, too, but only if you're going to read lots of books on this topic.If you are looking for a balanced book on this subject that is an easy read, I recommend "Contested Land, Contested Memory" by Roberts. If you are looking for a very thorough history lesson on this subject, I recommend "Righteous Victims" by Morris. Note: The Morris book is a royal rain to read. It's very long with lots of details. The Morris book is mostly balanced (more than Said's book), but not completely. (The author is a Jewish Israeli.)
Quality book in fine condition delivered in a timely way. Thanks.
In the introduction, the author states his purpose: "my aim has been to write a book putting before the western reader a broadly representative Palestinian position". I believe he accomplished the task with a nuanced and articulate expose. Further, he manages to present his case with minimal offense to the western reader.If you think it of value:1.to analyze the "western culture" psyche regarding "eastern culture".2.Understand the impact of Zionism on the native population3.know the goals of Zionismread this book.Some dislikes:In several places the author states that something is obvious or clear without and need not be elaborated. For an obtuse fellow like me, this was not helpful. End note 34 of final chapter missing.End of review.Mental residue:I believe historically, many populations may have been displaced. The American native as example. The Palestine case seems to be an anomaly regarding all the attention. In America, we have eminent domain by which people are displaced for the "benefit" of the whole. Regarding culture inferiority: the author argues that the 'west' sees the 'east' as inferior. In a strange way he seemed to validate the view that the east is inferior. That is from a power position. It seemed the natives did not know who they were and over time developed the "Palestinian" idea of themselves. From there the idea of self determination took shape. This metamorphosis gave them a greater power to resist Zionist.
Said is excellent, he said.
Does the fact that I am an Israeli Jew living in Israel mean that I should reject this book ? Does the fact that I think the book is crucially important mean that I am "taking sides" ?I believe otherwise. I found this book to be very important, as it is an account of a Palestinian - an admittedly interested party in the conflict. Said knows about the Jews and Zionism much more than most Israeli Jews know about the Palestinians. But of course - Said is never "objective" - he himself is a refugee, who describes the side of Zionism as he and many others like him experienced.Said shows surprising understanding of Zionism - he even says that one cannot compare the situation in Israel to that which existed in South Africa. He says that things here are more complicated. Said acknowledges the achievements of Zionism as far as Jews are concerned, another surprise.I felt a deep passion for peace and compromise in this book - I believe that the author accepts the reality of a Jewish state in Israel. However, Said points out that no such peace can be achieved as long as Palestinian dreams are constantly shattered or ignored.There are two sides to this story - I am on one and Said is on the other. Still, this book is important because it acknowledges the existance of two sides, and thus provides a road to conciliation that is so important to all of us.I think every Jew and every Paelstinian should read this book, and so should evreybody with a serious interest in our troubled piece of land.
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said PDF
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said EPub
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said Doc
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said iBooks
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said rtf
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said Mobipocket
The Question of Palestine, by Edward W. Said Kindle
0 komentar:
Posting Komentar